
Athlone, Cape Town, Western Cape
Muslim Judicial Council — Fatwa Department
- Fatawa
- 107
- Span
- 30 Mar 2022 – 9 Jul 2026
- Languages
- English
About MJCProfile, scholars & how to ask
Founded at a Muslim Progressive Society meeting in Cathedral Hall, Cape Town, under Chairman Shaykh M. Shakier Gamieldien; the original Supreme Council issued fatwas, a role now held by the Fatwa Committee headed by the Mufti and Qadi. The Majlis al-Ifta meets bi-monthly in Athlone so questions are debated before a fatwa is issued. Serves Shafi'i and Hanafi communities; 18 departments incl. Qada, Halaal Trust, arbitration. Notable for anti-apartheid stances and the 1980s Ahmadiyya court case. 'The Karaan Legacy' collects ~50 years of fatawa of Mufti Yusuf Karaan and Mufti Taha Karaan.
Founded: 10 February 1945
The MJC publishes only the fatwa title and answer, not the questioner’s text — here the title stands in for the question.
Have a question?
Fatawa SA is read-only. Ask Muslim Judicial Council — Fatwa Department directly: 20 Cashel Avenue, Athlone, Cape Town, 7764.
Scholars
ML Yaaseen Abass
Head of Fatwa (Mufti), MJC; Fatwa Committee; Imaarah member
Listed on the current MJC leadership page as head of the Fatwa department (Mufti) and member of the Imaarah and Fatwa Committee. The MJC biography is marked 'coming soon'; no teachers/lineage published.
SourceMufti Muhammad Taha Karaan (1969–2021)
Former Mufti / head of the MJC Fatwa Department (2015–2021); founder, Dar al-Uloom al-Arabiyyah al-Islamiyyah, Strand
Shafi'i scholar, son of MJC Mufti Yusuf Karaan; hifz in one year at Waterval Islamic Institute, then graduated from Darul Uloom Deoband in 1991 with top distinction and a two-year graduate diploma at the Higher Institute for Islamic Studies, Cairo. Founded DUAI in Strand (1996), headed the MJC Fatwa Department after his father's death and sat on the Muslim Personal Law Board, and led Islamic finance at ABSA and other institutions. Renowned polymath and calligrapher; died of COVID-19 on 11 June 2021.
SourceMufti Abdurragmaan Khan
Former MJC Mufti (appointed Oct 2021); Fatwa Committee since 2013; Rector, Dar al-Turath al-Islami
Hifz under Shaykh Ismail Londt (Dar Ubaiy, 2000); graduated from Dar al-Uloom al-Arabiyyah al-Islamiyyah, Strand (2006) under Mufti Taha Karaan, lecturing there 2006–2015. Founded Dar al-Turath al-Islami (2009), co-founded the Mahabbah Foundation (2011), joined the MJC Fatwa Committee in 2013 and was named Mufti in October 2021; many fatawa on the MJC library are answered by him.
SourceSH Nabeel (Nabiel) Majiet
Qadi (Head of Qada), MJC; Fatwa Committee member since 2008
Studied at Waterval Islamic Institute (1987–91), hifz at Darul Islam, then a BA (Hons) in Islamic Law (Comparative Fiqh) at Al-Azhar; further Honours and a Master's in Islamic Thought at IPSA, now a PhD candidate at UWC. Teaches Shafi'i fiqh and usul at Madina Institute SA, heads Islamic Studies at Al-Azhar High School, and is imam of Masjid Touhid, Parow Valley.
SourceML Zakariyya Harnekar
Fatwa Committee & Executive Council, MJC
Graduated in 2016 from the institution of Mufti Taha Karaan (DUAI), teaching there six years; since 2023 teaches at The Kurani Institute and part-time at Mizan Institute. Holds a BSc (Maths, UCT) and BA Hons (Arabic, UWC); interests in kalam and usul al-fiqh.
SourceML Siraaj Giri
Fatwa Committee member & administrator, MJC
Hifz under Sh Ismail Londt and Alimiyyah under Mufti Taha Karaan at DUAI, Strand, working directly under him in the Fatwa Department for his last three years; informal study in the Middle East incl. under Habib Umar. Founder/director of Al-Suffah and heads the academic programme at the Sumayah Foundation.
Source
Newest first · 107 fatawa
- MJC9 Jul 2026
Preventing Visitation of Grandparents
Assuming that by “biological father” you are referring to an Islamic father, meaning that the child was conceived within a marriage, please be…
Mufti Abdurragmaan Khan; Research Assistant: Sh/ - MJC9 Jul 2026
The Transformation of Wine to Vinegar
Assuming you are referring to vinegar that does not carry certification from a recognized scholarly body, please note the following: While the…
Mufti Abdurragmaan Khan; Research Assistant: Mln - MJC18 May 2026
Death Benefits and Inheritance
Concerning your query, please be advised: 1. The death benefit is a lump sum paid to an employee’s beneficiaries or dependents in the event of his…
Mufti Abdurragmaan Khan; Research Assistant: Sh/ - MJC3 May 2026
Is an Umrah Ticket Competition Permissible?
1. Gambling (qimar) is where two or more parties wager money with the possibility of either gaining the entire amount or losing their stake. 2. The…
Mufti Abdurragmaan Khan; Research Assistant: Mln - MJC10 Feb 2026
An Explanation on Fitrah and Fidyah calculation
1. The Ḥanafī School is the only school that permits the payment of Fidyah and Fiṭrah in cash. Historically, Cape Shafi’ī Muslims have adopted the…
Mufti Abdurragmaan Khan - MJC13 Jan 2026
The mīqāt for pilgrims traveling with Ethiopian Airlines to Jeddah
With regards to your query please be advised: The mīqāt for pilgrims traveling with Ethiopian Airlines to Jeddah is Yalamlam. The pilot usually…
Mufti Abdurragmaan Khan - MJC16 Dec 2025
Are Credit Cards Permissible To Use?
Regarding your query, please be advised: 1. Credit cards function as a three-party transaction involving a buyer, a seller, and a financial…
Mufti Abdurragmaan Khan; Research Assistant: Mln - MJC18 Nov 2025
Effect of Apostasy on Marriage
With regards to your query, please be informed of the following: Please be hereby informed that when any of the parties to an Islamic marriage…
Mufti Taha Karaan - MJC18 Nov 2025
Seeking Debt Counselling
With regards to your query regarding the permissibility of seeking debt counseling, please be advised: Our understanding of the process of debt…
Mufti Abdurragmaan Khan - MJC21 Oct 2025
Killing Fish with Electric Shock
With regards to your query, please be informed of the following: 1. The Sharīʿah does not prescribe any specific method for killing fish. Any method…
Mufti Taha Karaan - MJC21 Oct 2025
Cakes with Bible Verses and Crucifix
With reference to your query, please be informed: 1. A crucifix, in its traditional form as commonly displayed in churches and the like, represents…
Mufti Abdurragmaan Khan; Research Assistant: Dr. - MJC28 Sep 2025
Overdrafts
With regards to your query, please be informed of the following: 1. An overdraft is a credit facility which a bank provides to an account holder, in…
Mufti Taha Karaan - MJC28 Sep 2025
Fathers Duty Towards his Unmarried Daughter
With regards to your query, please be informed of the following: 1. A father is financially responsible for the basic needs of his poor children who…
Mufti Abdurragmaan Khan; Research Assistant: Ml - MJC19 Jul 2025
Are Women Punished More than Men on the Day of Judgement?
With reference to your query, please be informed as follows: 1. The mentioned hadith is categorized as slightly weak, indicating that it should not…
Mufti Abdurragmaan Khan - MJC11 Jul 2025
The Practice of Reiki
With reference to your query, please be informed as follows: 1. From the texts of our scholars, it is apparent that anyone engaging in medical…
Mufti Abdurragmaan Khan; Research Assistant: Dr - MJC25 Jun 2025
Disposal of Specimens belonging to Muslims not collected from the lab
1. In Islam, parts severed from a living body deserve the same respect accorded to a deceased body. 2. Such respect is demonstrated through burial,…
Mufti Taha Karaan - MJC25 Jun 2025
Does Cat Hair on Your Clothing Invalidate the Salah?
According to the main view in the Shāfiʿī school, cat hair that is separated from a living cat will be considered impure. However, according to an…
Mufti Abdurragmaan Khan - MJC17 Jun 2025
Assistance to Parents
1. As a rule, the Sharīʿah holds children—both male and female—responsible for maintaining their parents where parents are no longer able to…
Mufti Taha Karaan - MJC17 Jun 2025
ًWhat is the Ruling on Phone Contracts with Services?
1. The contract includes both the physical phone and services such as data, airtime, and SMSs. Since separate prices are shown for the phone and the…
Mufti Abdurragmaan Khan; Research Assistant: Ml - MJC3 Jun 2025
Is Nikāḥ Valid Without a Wali?
1. A woman is not permitted to marry without the consent of her wali (guardian). The Prophet ﷺ explicitly stated, “There is no valid nikah without a…
Mufti Abdurragmaan Khan - MJC30 Apr 2025
Female Nasheed Groups in front of Male audience
1. In principle, the voice of a strange woman is not considered ‘awrah. 2. As such, general communication is regarded permissible. However, there…
Mln Siraaj Girie - MJC30 Apr 2025
Breastmilk Banking
1. Interest in the Sharʿī status of milk banks and their social consequences was first raised in the 80s. Scholarly opinion at the time was divided.…
Mufti Taha Karaan - MJC18 Jan 2025
Keeping Snakes as Pets
1. In light of situations that might and do arise, the need for expert snake handlers in society is readily recognized. 2. Since this need can be…
Mufti Taha Karaan - MJC18 Jan 2025
Is Making Origami Shapes Permissible?
Origami, which is the art of paper folding into shapes and figures, would be considered permissible when making shapes or figures of inanimate…
Mufti Abdurragmaan Khan; Research Assistant: Ml - MJC11 Dec 2024
Calculations and Rules of ‘Iddah
1. Calculation of the ‘iddah 1.1. The ‘iddah following ṭalāq is calculated in terms of the menstrual cycle in the following manner: 1.1.1. The…
Mufti Taha Karaan - MJC11 Dec 2024
Responsibilities of a Stepfather
The stepfather has no financial obligation towards his stepchild. In the absence of the actual father, the responsibility for the child’s…
Mufti Abdurragmaan Khan; Research Assistant: Mln - MJC29 Nov 2024
Non-Compliant Will
1. It remains a most regrettable phenomenon that Muslims continue to make wills that do not comply to Sharīʿah, despite the wide latitude that South…
Mufti Taha Karaan - MJC29 Nov 2024
Female Studying Abroad
1. A woman is permitted to move out of her parents’ or maḥram’s (unmarriageable kin’s) home to live independently or with other women, subject to…
Mufti Abdurragmaan Khan - MJC21 Nov 2024
Hajj from Pension Funds
1. Funds received from a pension scheme may be divided into 3 distinct categories: A. the portion that was subtracted from the employee’s salary; B.…
Mufti Taha Karaan - MJC21 Nov 2024
How does one Perform Wudu and Salah with Constant Release of Impurities?
May Allah grant you relief from your medical difficulties and help you find a lasting solution for your ailments. Remember, Allah does not place a…
Mufti Abdurragmaan Khan; Research Assistant: Dr